Another one bites the dust! Rascal Flatts took the stage at Sunday’s Academy of Country Music awards show but soon wished someone, anyone could have hit Rewind.

It seems someone on the crew hit the “play button” at the wrong time, and the watchful eye of the internet noticed in a big way..

Even the press noticed something was amiss…

USA TODAY’s Brian Mansfield hinted at it in his show recap, writing: “Flatts sounded as perfect performing their new single as they’ve ever sounded on television. Maybe a little too perfect.”