TROY, OH. (THECOUNT) — Caleb Flynn, the former Ohio pastor and “American Idol” contestant convicted of murdering his wife, Ashley Flynn, is scheduled to be sentenced Monday in Miami County Common Pleas Court, where he faces the possibility of life in prison without parole.
Flynn, 40, was found guilty September 29 of aggravated murder, three counts of murder, two counts of felonious assault and three counts of tampering with evidence in connection with Ashley’s February 2026 shooting death at the couple’s home in Tipp City, north of Dayton. Jurors also found firearm specifications attached to several of the charges.
Advertisement
The jury reached its verdict after approximately 2 1/2 hours of deliberation following a more than weeklong trial. Flynn became emotional as the guilty verdicts were read in court.
Prosecutors alleged Flynn shot Ashley, 37, twice in the back of the head while she was in bed on February 16, then staged the home to make it appear an intruder had broken in. Flynn called 911 and reported that a burglar had entered the home and shot his wife.
Investigators did not find evidence supporting the reported home invasion, prosecutors argued. The garage door showed damage that investigators said was inconsistent with an actual forced entry, and the firearm prosecutors said was used in the killing has never been recovered.
The prosecution’s case also centered heavily on Flynn’s relationship with Alleigha Botner, a former mistress who testified that she and Flynn had carried on an affair after meeting in 2022 when she was an intern at his church.
Botner testified about more than 100,000 messages exchanged between her and Flynn, including communications in which prosecutors said Flynn expressed hatred toward Ashley and discussed ways she could be killed. Prosecutors argued the messages, digital evidence and physical evidence from the home contradicted Flynn’s account of an intruder.
Among the evidence presented to jurors were messages in which Flynn allegedly discussed killing Ashley while avoiding prison. Prosecutors also presented AI-generated love songs Flynn had created for Botner.
Flynn did not testify during the trial, and the defense called no witnesses. His attorneys argued the prosecution’s case was circumstantial and pointed to the absence of the murder weapon, the lack of an eyewitness and the fact that investigators found no gunshot residue on Flynn.
Defense attorney Patrick Mulligan said after the verdict that he expected the defense to pursue an appeal, citing an alleged lack of evidence supporting prior calculation and design.
Ashley’s family said following the verdict that they were grateful for the jury’s decision and refused to allow the circumstances surrounding her death to define her life. They described Ashley as a devoted mother whose faith, kindness and love for her family were central to who she was.
Ashley was a teacher and volleyball coach. Her school district previously described her as a caring and dedicated educator who made a positive impact both in the classroom and on the volleyball court.
Flynn had gained brief national exposure years before the killing when he appeared on Season 12 of “American Idol” in 2013. During his televised audition, he performed for judges Mariah Carey, Randy Jackson and Nicki Minaj, although he did not advance to the Hollywood rounds.
During the audition, Flynn credited Ashley with encouraging him to pursue his musical ambitions and spoke publicly about his love for his wife.
The sentencing hearing is scheduled for Monday afternoon in the Miami County courtroom in Troy. Flynn faces up to life in prison without parole following his conviction for aggravated murder and the other offenses.
The sentencing marks the next major phase in a case that began with Flynn’s early-morning 911 call reporting that an intruder had shot his wife and ultimately ended with a jury rejecting that account and finding him guilty on all charges.
Tipp City is located in Miami County in southwestern Ohio, approximately 15 miles north of Dayton. The sentencing proceedings are being held at the Miami County Common Pleas Court in Troy, the county seat.
Google Maps: Miami County Common Pleas Court, Troy, OH
DEVELOPING::